Fear The Sword: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: Along The Olentangy for Ohio State Fans!

Defending Lebron

So, the smoke has settled on the biggest free agent decision in the history of the NBA. Love it or hate it, Lebron James is now a member of the Miami Heat, and most people, especially those in the media, seem to hate it. There were so many elements to his decision and the way he decided to announce it.  How will it affect the landscape of the NBA? Was the one hour TV special the right way to break the news? Should loyalty exist in sports? Let’s take a look at these questions and try to provide a little bit of clarity.

Loyalty in sports

Before I get into my thoughts on the TV special and the decision’s impact on the NBA, let’s take a look at loyalty, or Lebron’s lack thereof according to some. Loyalty in sports is over rated. Why should an athlete have to be loyal to a city and team? Because he was drafted by them and the fans show up and cheer? Does that mean he should be stuck there for his entire career? I don’t think so. Calling Lebron disloyal is unfair. It’s not Lebron’s fault that he was drafted by the Cavs, but it is the Cavs fault for not building a good enough team around him. The fans should blame the Cavs organization, not Lebron. Lebron did more for the Cavs than the Cavs did for Lebron, plain and simple.

When an ordinary person leaves their job for a much better opportunity, they’re called anything but disloyal. I realize that Lebron leaving the Cavs for the Heat is much more different than an ordinary person leaving Burger King for a gig at Applebee’s, but what about other people who make a living in the entertainment industry? Steve Carrell for example, recently announced that he’ll be leaving the hit TV show ‘The Office’ to spend more time with his family and to concentrate on making movies. If you think about it, this isn’t much different from Lebron’s situation. Carrell is leaving for a better opportunity, but as a result The Office will suffer tremendously without him and sooner than later the series will come end because it’s most popular character is no longer there. As a result, the millions of the fans that the show has will be disappointed that one of their favorite shows is off the air. Why aren’t people accusing Carrell of being disloyal? You could strongly argue that The Office made his career, therefore he should stick it out and be loyal to the show’s creators and to NBC. In no way did the Cavs make Lebron. It’s not like he got his big break with them, like Carrell did on The Office, so why is one strongly accused of being a disloyal backstabber while the other is wished good luck and given a pat on the back?

The bottom line is that professional athlete’s owe nothing to no one except themselves, their families and the people who helped get them where they are. There’s of course cases like a Gilbert Arenas or Michael Vick, who’s teams are taking a risk and giving them a chance, but this isn’t the case for Lebron. He simply wants to be better, and that wasn’t going to happen with the Cavs.

To read the more of my thoughts on Lebron's decision, please visit - http://whatupsports.wordpress.com/2010/07/14/defending-lebron/




This is a Fan-Created Comment on FearTheSword.com. The opinion here is not necessarily shared by the editorial staff at FearTheSword

1 recs  |  Comment 48 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

I see some of your points, but still think you’re off base. For one the Cavs DID build a good enough team around him. The Cavs went to the Finals with nobody and surrounded him with sharpshooters, role players, bench scoring and veteran big men. What they didn’t give him was a good coach. Even then, noone will dispute that the 60 win teams from the last 2 years were MUCH better than the Finals team, so what happened?
As for the Cavs not doing anything for Lebron, also off base. If anything they gave him too much to were he either felt entitled, greedy, what have you. How many players get there friends jobs within the organization?
 The only valid point I think you have is the loyalty bit. Yes he was a free agent, he’s entitled to go where he wants, but it’s how he did it. If LBJ had done like D-wade and said he was staying put in Cleveland and signed a contract, then players would have come here. We couldn’t sign any FA’s b/c no-one knew where LBJ was playing. The way he tied the organizations hands and the effect that he will have on it’s future is despicable.

I’m gonna leave the Steve Carrell thing alone. If you’re comparing the feelings fans have for their professional sports teams to “fans” of a TV show, then most of what I’m saying and anyone else for that matter will be lost on you.
 But thanks for the post anyway, it makes for good topic discussion and that’s what the blogs are about.

College basketball just became more interesting...

by allovertheplace on Jul 22, 2010 9:14 AM CDT reply actions   2 recs

Seriously?

I will not thank you for your post. Try doing some reading before you go on about something that you clearly don’t understand.

Dude, stick to what you know. Based on what you have written, I am not sure what that might be, (clearly it isn’t grammar), but there must be something.

Every pessimist thinks himself a realist. In the case of Cleveland sports fans, they are probably right.

by evereye3 on Jul 22, 2010 11:34 AM CDT reply actions  

Try doing some reading? What are you talking about? Sorry about the mistakes professor, my editor wasn’t around to proof read the article for me.

I can somewhat understand how a bitter Cavs fan wouldn’t understand the situation.

by TheJoeOsborne on Jul 22, 2010 7:46 PM CDT up reply actions  

wow…really?

Sorry about the mistakes professor, my editor wasn’t around to proof read the article for me.

no need to be snarky. I think it was clear he wasn’t talking about spell check kind of stuff but the fact it was clear all you have probably read was ESPN sucking on Lebron’s nuts. for the real story, check out Wojo. i usually don’t like him because he has been anti-lebron over the past, but he has always had good sources, and about 60% of the stuff in his article is a reiteration of what the cavs beat writer uncovered in a column recently (a guy who owes a lot career-wise to lebron).

Just because someone is a cavs fan, doesn’t mean every single view they have of the situation is irrational…and its not just cavs fans speaking out. Its HOF player like Magic and Michael. Buzz Bissinger, the guy who wrote Lebron’s Biography…the list goes on and on.

I teach good life choices. That’s why I almost didn’t graduate High School.

by bross09 on Jul 22, 2010 9:33 PM CDT up reply actions  

The story was intended to be one sided, hence the title ‘Defending Lebron’. I would like to read the article you mention if you can provide a link.

I realize there’s a lot of people against the move to the Heat, and that’s why I like it. It took some major balls to do what he did, and it’s something that’s never been done before.

by TheJoeOsborne on Jul 23, 2010 7:10 AM CDT up reply actions  

The story was intended to be one sided, hence the title ‘Defending Lebron’

so you decided to ignore he other side of the story and just write a slanted editorial then? This sounds like Fox News material. Its an editorial and an opinion piece, but you also include several bits of fact in there, but only defending one side. It is in some ways less an opinion piece than slanted journalism.

Adrian Wojo article:

http://sports.yahoo.com/nba/news?slug=aw-heatfreeagency071610

Brian Windhorst (the first one I actually juts found but it also is relevant):

http://www.cleveland.com/cavs/index.ssf/2010/07/it_was_after_lebron_james_sign.html

http://www.cleveland.com/cavs/index.ssf/2010/07/inside_the_decision_miamis_cou.html

All of these point to a guy who completely manipulated his former team possibly so he could get to his current team. There is a difference between having balls and being a straight up douche. Does TO have balls? Does Barry Bonds have Balls? Roger Clemens? All these guys are huge assholes in sports…Lebron is no smaller, so why is it just for him “having balls”. There was more than just doing something that people didn’t like. It was a pattern of inconsiderate behavior towards the cavs.

I teach good life choices. That’s why I almost didn’t graduate High School.

by bross09 on Jul 23, 2010 8:01 AM CDT up reply actions  

Dear Professor,

The article was an opinion based piece on why I think Lebron is being treated unfairly. Since most seem to be against Lebron, I think my of my thoughts are pretty independent. Congrats on your success as a class A nerd. You come on here thinking you’re the smartest person on the internet in an attempt to sound smart and get a pat on the back from a bunch of people you don’t even know. Why not try having an original opinion, and putting yourself in Lebron’s shoes instead of siding with everyone else. I’m all about a good debate, but stick to the topic, and keep the ‘Fox News’ crap out of it.

by TheJoeOsborne on Jul 23, 2010 7:20 AM CDT up reply actions   1 recs

I think my of my thoughts are pretty independent.

I would have to disagree. Independent would be looking at all the facts and making a decision independently of what people think. You seem to just like bucking the trend and saying you are an “independent” but instead just are trying to choose an option that no one else chooses for the sake of making yourself look independent.

<blockquoteCongrats on your success as a class A nerd. You come on here thinking you’re the smartest person on the internet>

wow….resorting to ad hominem attacks instead of a valid point? I hate to tell ya, but a lot of people on SBN blogs are not idiots and try not to be. The internet is not just a place full of idiots…and why do you have to insult someone for intelligent reasoned argument unless you feel emasculated by it?

I can’t put myself in lebron’s shoes because I just can’t do what he did. I can’t tattoo loyalty on my arm and promise my boss the world and the simultaneously make covert plans with my friends to work together. That is not at all in my character.

I teach good life choices. That’s why I almost didn’t graduate High School.

by bross09 on Jul 23, 2010 8:08 AM CDT up reply actions   1 recs

why is it bad to be smart? should well educated people feel bad for being smarter than you?

I have been complimented many times and they always embarrass me; I always feel that they have not said enough.

by notthatnoise on Jul 23, 2010 12:28 PM CDT up reply actions   1 recs

Your “independent” opinion has been being voiced for the past two weeks by every other idiot who hasn’t even begun to look into the issue. Try looking in the comments section of any and every article about LeSham’s decision, there a million more just like you; uninformed and unashamed to show it.

I don’t pretend to be the smartest person on the internet. I read the articles of people who actually have more expertise, or are closer to the situation than I am. I think through the material there and then post my opinions having actually been informed.

It is you who believes that he has outsmarted us all; you who thinks that he has had the blindingly brilliant insight that

professional athlete’s owe nothing to no one except themselves
a thought so beyond the capabilities of we the unwashed masses, that we need you to bestow it upon us.

I get enough pats on the back at home and work. I post here to have an informed conversation about the Cavs with other people who actually follow them, actually know what they are talking about, and actually are willing to admit when they don’t know something.

I will leave the debate on the line by line content of your “article” to others, as they have already done a good enough job taking you to school and exposing what an uninformed ass you are.

I will say this about your “bottom line” though. Who exactly was it that helped LeEgo get where he is, if it wasn’t the fans (who paid for the tickets, jerseys and merchandise that funded his paycheck), his teammates (who passed him the ball when he wanted it and did as he commanded on the floor), his coaches (who gave him essentially player-coach level in-game decision authority), and the management and ownership of the Cavaliers (who attempted to get every player he suggested, who gave him veto authority over every personnel decision that was made, who gave jobs to his high school buddies, who built a practice facility closer to his house to cut down on his commute, and gave him anything else that he asked for that wasn’t against the rules of the league)? Who else could he possibly have owed anything to?

The sad truth is that I have spent way too much time trying to understand the issue from LeFraud’s point of view, and anyway you slice it, it was the disloyal act of a man-child so frightened that his self-image would falter if he never won a championship, that he jumped ship, left his work undone and his promises unfulfilled, and took what he perceived would be less pressure and more fun, an easy way out.

You sir are not “all about a good debate”. You came in here to stir up the hornets’ nest and tell us all that we are bitter idiots for holding our views, when those views are incomparably more informed than your own. If you want me to keep Fox News out of it, then don’t argue with the same pathetic psuedo-reasoning.

Every pessimist thinks himself a realist. In the case of Cleveland sports fans, they are probably right.

by evereye3 on Jul 23, 2010 12:53 PM CDT up reply actions   4 recs

If only I could give multiple recs…

I have been complimented many times and they always embarrass me; I always feel that they have not said enough.

by notthatnoise on Jul 23, 2010 12:29 PM CDT up reply actions  

lol. I was just trying to be nice. I was bored at work and it was the only new post up

College basketball just became more interesting...

by allovertheplace on Jul 23, 2010 10:32 AM CDT up reply actions  

too soon , man too soon

Im the poor man's corey maggette!!!

by Chucky Brown on Jul 22, 2010 12:47 PM CDT reply actions  

Pass…written by a jilted raptors fan who wants the attention away from lebron b/c he doesn’t feel recognized for his heartbreak.

I teach good life choices. That’s why I almost didn’t graduate High School.

by bross09 on Jul 22, 2010 2:55 PM CDT reply actions  

LeBron said that he "doesn't want to go ring chasing and wants to bring a championship to Cleveland"

So yes, it was EXTREMELY wrong of him to not only quit on his promise, but to have a 1 hour special pretty much exclusively to say fu** you to Cleveland. Also, you don’t win championships by being on a t.v. show. Are you really comparing sports and t.v. shows right now? That argument not only makes 0 sense, but it was thought out very poorly. Steve Carell did not promise to deliver Emmy’s to the show, even though he did, numerous times, while LeBron did promise championships, but quit. It’s not so much that LeBron left that made him sports enemy #1 on most people’s list, it’s HOW he did it. Even though he promised championships, if he just told the front office that he would be leaving after his contract expired, like Steve Carell did, the Cavaliers would have been prepared and have had time to think of a reconstruction plan instead of screwing themselves over by trading for Antawn Jamison. Steve Carell didn’t screw The Office for a better show, he wanted more flexibility and time to spend with his family, which is extremely reasonable coming from a 47 year old man who has been working in movies and The Office endlessly for 5 straight years. What do Steve Carell and LeBron James have in common? Other than the fact that they are both men, pretty much nothing.

Idiot.

by EhondA on Jul 22, 2010 5:49 PM CDT reply actions  

Wow, I’m the idiot? You’re the wanna be tough guy who talks trash to a stranger on a fan blog. I obviously know the difference between an actor and an athlete, but it’s a fun comparison that shows that sports fans take things too serious.

The hour special wasn’t intended at all as an ‘FU’ to Cavs fans, even though the bitter fans of Cleveland think so. The media made a spectacle out of free agency, and Lebron tried to exploit it.

Lebron did his part to try to bring a championship to Cleveland, but team management didn’t do their part. Put Kobe on a team with the same players, and he wouldn’t win either.

Thanks for your opinion though. I’m happy that I could provide an outlet for your anger.

by TheJoeOsborne on Jul 22, 2010 7:44 PM CDT up reply actions  

You’re the wanna be tough guy who talks trash to a stranger on a fan blog

A: he really isn’t talking that much trash.
B: don’t get so sensitive…you need to have a thick skin on the internet
C: You are going to ask for this sort of thing when you post something pretty much saying “all cavs fans are irrational idiots for how they acted with lebron”, especially without doing all the proper research on the subject.

The hour special wasn’t intended at all as an ‘FU’ to Cavs fans

then what was it then?

The media made a spectacle out of free agency, and Lebron tried to exploit it.

No…the other way around. Lebron made a spectacle out of the situation from the beginning and the media (especially ESPN) exploited it. Even if you go back a few years…the media didn’t make such a huge deal until lebron said and did things (like wearing a yankees cap in a way that was pretty clear to draw attention to it) to make them think he was thinking something. He would give very vague and ambiguous answers to questions that may have been intentionally misleading…he mislead the whole new york media.

Lebron did his part to try to bring a championship to Cleveland, but team management didn’t do their part.

that is where you are wrong. Since Danny Ferry came to the cavs and Dan Gilbert started to own the team, the cavs were always one of the most ACTIVE teams at free agency and at the trading deadline. The management did all they could.

Here is the short list of Players they went out and go
Larry Hughes
Antwan Jamison
Ben Wallace
Wally Z
Antwan Jamison
Joe Smith
Mo Williams
Delonte

Most of these guys are solid starters while some of the others are just good role players.

Give Kobe Shaq, Jamison, and a good shooting point guard and He at least makes the finals this year…

I teach good life choices. That’s why I almost didn’t graduate High School.

by bross09 on Jul 22, 2010 9:43 PM CDT up reply actions   1 recs

Proper research on the subject? You’re an idiot. I know the facts, and this article was based on my opinion. What type of research do you suggest I do?

It wasn’t an FU to Cavs fans, even though they might see it that way. I admit, if I was a Cavs fan, I might feel the same way. But there’s no way Lebron and his people actually got together and said “Let’s really try to f*ck with these people.” It was intended as a way to promote himself and his brand. I do admit, that it did backfire a bit, but you have to admit that it made for great entertainment. The whole free agency thing was turned into an event, so he embraced it. As for the Yankees hat, that was blown way out of proportion by the media. The guy is a Yankees fan, it’s not like we was walking around town wearing a Knicks jersey. No matter what he did, the media was gonna spin it in the opposite direction of his decision.

That list of players is pretty sad. Joe Smith and Wally Z? You really think they could be a major part of a championship rotation? Shaq and Wallace were way past their primes when they arrived. Having Antawn as your second best player wouldn’t get any team deep into the playoffs.

by TheJoeOsborne on Jul 23, 2010 7:34 AM CDT up reply actions  

You’re an idiot

ad hominem?

I know the facts,

well you ignored every single fact that would incriminate lebron

and this article was based on my opinion. What type of research do you suggest I do

how about not write an opinion piece that is a thinly veiled ad hominem attack with no true legitimate argument…and if you want to make a legitimate argument and defend lebron on certain issues, it would be wise to actually have facts about the situation or issue.

But there’s no way Lebron and his people actually got together and said "Let’s really try to f*ck with these people

yeah…He didn’t intentionally want to screw with the cavs but just planned 2 years ago to leave, threw a playoff series to give himself an excuse to leave (this I admit is somewhat questionable), not at all contact his OWN TEAM during the whole process, and then pretty much break up with them in front of the whole US on TV without even talking to them at all…Its been months since Lebron talked to gilbert. There is no way so many malicious ‘accidents’ can all happen.

The whole free agency thing was turned into an event, so he embraced it.

You keep saying this as if it was a fact…but the facts are more than he created free agency into an event so the media embraced it.

As for the Yankees hat, that was blown way out of proportion by the media. The guy is a Yankees fan, it’s not like we was walking around town wearing a Knicks jersey

a couple things. When the yankees incident happened, Lebron had already been openly flirting WHILE UNDER CONTRACT with the knicks in subtle ways. He was flirting so much that the knicks cleared all that cap space. Lebron is a tease and this is the equivalent of someone flirting with a married man at work and saying all this sexy stuff in his ear and then when he divorces his wife, say you aren’t interested.

Also, lebron wore the hat at an indians playoff game when they were playing the yankees. Instead of supporting the hometown team and making the city think he was loyal to them, he wore a hat of their opponent. He had a good excuse since he said he was a yankees fan when he was a kid. However, he has NEVER shown any loyalty to the city of cleveland. He has loyalty from akron but he made sure to make the distinction.

All press conferences and awards ceremonies he had were not in cleveland, they were in his hometown of akron (which is just a bit south of cleveland but its own separate city). He never talked about loyalty to the city which was a sign we all missed. He was loyal to akron but when it came down to showing loyalty to the city of cleveland, he skirted the issue by doing things like the yankees hat instead of showing support to fellow cleveland athletes. He even drove Braylon Edwards out of town by making a big deal about Edwards getting into a scuffle with one of his entourage and calling Edwards ‘jealous’. These are all signs that he never really liked cleveland and was always trying to distance himself.

That list of players is pretty sad. Joe Smith and Wally Z? You really think they could be a major part of a championship rotation? Shaq and Wallace were way past their primes when they arrived. Having Antawn as your second best player wouldn’t get any team deep into the playoffs

I disagree with all of this.

Wally Z made the conference finals before and has been a key part of winning teams. Worse players have been part of championship rotations. Shaq was way past his prime but the year before he was an 18 and 8 player…he just ran into injuries last year. Having Rashard Lewis as your best player shouldn’t get you far but it got the Magic to the NBA Finals…

Looking at it objectively, Shaq, Jamison, and Mo for us last year were no worse than the combination of Jameer nelson coming off an injury in the playoffs, Hedo, and Rashard…but that was still almost a championship team. Teams have won championships with worse second players on their team…it just takes some decent coaching.

I teach good life choices. That’s why I almost didn’t graduate High School.

by bross09 on Jul 23, 2010 8:29 AM CDT up reply actions  

Interesting.

Hello bross. Don’t worry I won’t be rude to you.

This is a fascinating claim, although there’s a problem with this “solid” supporting cast you claim to have in Cleveland (that Kobe would take to the Finals according to you).

It isn’t true, because Kobe has a 103.9 Offensive rating (per 32% possessions) against top ten defenses.

That is an inferior and unimpressive level. Kobe does not play well against good defenses, his cast is simply more consistent.

by agradecimiento a dios on Aug 1, 2010 7:54 AM CDT up reply actions  

I love how you have to drag Kobe into it. This comment was about the MAGIC team and not at all about Kobe. You talk about how much you hate him, but I have never heard someone talk about another person they hate, so much.

I teach good life choices. That’s why I almost didn’t graduate High School.

I appreciate Male Beauty

Intensive Purposes? I could care less...

by bross09 on Aug 1, 2010 1:17 PM CDT up reply actions  

it doesnt matter whether it was ~intended~ to be a FU to cavs fans

because it was a FU to cavs fans. Whether he intended or not.

by spinz on Jul 23, 2010 1:00 AM CDT up reply actions  

The bottom line is that professional athlete’s owe nothing to no one except themselves, their families and the people who helped get them where they are

This is the outlook that has helped generate the selfish, self-centered, egotistical attitude that now permeates vast segments of the country. If you believe what you just posted, it looks like you’re another part of the problem.

Like it or not, LeBron doesn’t live in a vacuum (although his decision-making process indicates that he feels otherwise). He made promises that he didn’t keep. He gave up in our last playoff series. He didn’t have the dignity or courage to talk to the CAVS ownership before his special began. In fact, HE didn’t talk to them at all. Instead he engaged in his hour-long ego-trip that made a mockery of sports coverage, its stars, and the people he claimed to be loyal to.

Choices have consequences. The reaction of the people of the general area that raised him and made him what he became is a prime example of such a consequence.

Also, your comparison to what Steve Carrell is doing is really pretty asinine and non-comparable. If you can’t figure out why that is, then that’s pretty sad.

by darkcorvus70 on Jul 23, 2010 6:48 AM CDT reply actions  

I didn’t hear any Cavs fans say Lebron quit during the playoffs until he decided to leave the team. If Lebron’s contract with the Heat was somehow voided, Cavs fans would welcome him back with open arms and forget all about it.

If you’re to leave your job a Subway for a job at Quizno’s, do you think you should have to discuss it with your bosses at Subway first? That’s not how it works. Lebron left one organization for another, and people are making too big of a deal out of it.

I know there’s a difference between an actor and an athlete, but their both in the entertainment industry. Fans and a city think they own a player and shouldn’t be personally offended by their decisions.

by TheJoeOsborne on Jul 23, 2010 7:42 AM CDT up reply actions  

I didn’t hear any Cavs fans say Lebron quit during the playoffs until he decided to leave the team.

then you weren’t listening hard enough. My dad was saying that the one game he choked and that series was just a sign that he wasn’t coming back because it would give him an excuse since they didn’t win it all. This opinion was voiced by many. Lebron had one of the worst playoff performances in history.

If Lebron’s contract with the Heat was somehow voided, Cavs fans would welcome him back with open arms and forget all about it.

Nope. After all that has come out, most of us just don’t want him back. I see him as in some ways a bad seed.

If you’re to leave your job a Subway for a job at Quizno’s, do you think you should have to discuss it with your bosses at Subway first? That’s not how it works

actually, yeah thats how it works…or at least oftentimes works. You do not understand the business world really. You are completely in your rights to leave your job at subway for quiznos without telling your boss. Whether it should be done or not is a completely different question.

If you do that in pretty much the same way lebron did it, the boss isn’t going to send an angry letter like gilbert did, but you should not ever put subway on your resume or use it on a job application because you will have a terrible reference from them. The same thing happens in the business world but people suffer the consequences. Lebron is not immune to these consequences so why are you trying to say he is?

Fans and a city think they own a player and shouldn’t be personally offended by their decisions.

wow…have you been listening to Jesse Jackson too much? Fans do not have a feeling of ownership over a player. They might feel proud of ‘having’ a player on ‘their team’ if the player is good. However fans are understanding about Free Agency. Fans however are not understanding about intentional deceit.

I teach good life choices. That’s why I almost didn’t graduate High School.

by bross09 on Jul 23, 2010 8:37 AM CDT up reply actions  

If you’re to leave your job a Subway for a job at Quizno’s, do you think you should have to discuss it with your bosses at Subway first? That’s not how it works

you must be like 12 and can’t possibly have had a job. at almost ANY job you get, they require 2 weeks notice before quitting.

I have been complimented many times and they always embarrass me; I always feel that they have not said enough.

by notthatnoise on Jul 23, 2010 12:35 PM CDT up reply actions  

and if you decide to not tell them you quit until you show up after a shift at quiznos in your new uniform, forget ever putting that place on your reference sheet…that is pretty much what lebron did.

I teach good life choices. That’s why I almost didn’t graduate High School.

by bross09 on Jul 23, 2010 2:48 PM CDT up reply actions  

Now now, let’s not be to hard on him. It’s fairly obvious that he has a job. After all, he’s evidently getting a lot of work as a contract laborer who makes Straw-Men for a living.

by darkcorvus70 on Jul 24, 2010 10:28 AM CDT up reply actions  

Wow. At first I thought you were actually trying to show a different perspective and provide a topic for discussion, but reading the above post it seems you’re just here to start arguments and be a hate mongerer.
 Go to espn and read part 1 of bill simmons article. He makes some great points. As you say he was a free agent and he can go anywhere. But even forgetting the unforgivable way of how he did it, the fact remained that he went to Miami with 2 other superstars.
 I don’t know if you’ve ever played a sport, which I’m seriously doubting, but maybe you can understand the concept of the spirit of competition, and that you only get better by testing your skills against similar to better opponents. After the a-hole promises championsgips to the city of Cleveland, and tells the world we’ll be fine “because they have me”, he realized he wasn’t good enough to do it.
Even as a kid, when you pick teams you don’t put the best players on the same team. That’s not fun. And if the best players are on the same team, noone wants to play with them b/c it sucks. This hurts the league and the balance of the team. Miami for the most part will have no competion. Maybe “fans” like you would like to see a team go undefeated in the playoffs for years but the rest of us wouldn’t even watch that crap.
it was a punk move, plain and simple, and there’s really no way you can defend that.

College basketball just became more interesting...

by allovertheplace on Jul 23, 2010 10:58 AM CDT reply actions  

You may be able to excuse WHAT he did as “just business”, but NO ONE can say that, from an ethical standpoint, he did it the correct way.
I could go back and find quotes from the past couple of years where he told reporters and fans alike that he had “unfinished business” in Cleveland until the Cavs had won a championship..
Plain and simple..he stopped believing in himself as an elite player and ran off to ride the coattails of a rival to a (hoped for) championship.
How long do you think it will be before he becomes a cancer to the Heat because DWade is the man in town and he’s just the sidekick?

by cavslandrocks on Jul 23, 2010 4:56 PM CDT reply actions  

You are posting here to drive traffic to your website. You SUCK and you are annoying.

Denver: 32-32 until we're not.

by McGeorge on Jul 24, 2010 9:05 AM CDT reply actions  

“The bottom line is that professional athlete’s owe nothing to no one except themselves, their families and the people who helped get them where they are.”

Yeah, in this case his family and the people who helped him get where he is today are the same people he just abandoned.

Analysis fail.

by fivekmd on Jul 28, 2010 11:49 AM CDT reply actions  

I’m sure Lebron’s family doesn’t feel abandoned. You can’t make claims like that because you don’t know. His family has a better lifestyle thanks to him, so what’s best for him is best for them.

by TheJoeOsborne on Jul 30, 2010 1:29 PM CDT up reply actions  

I’m sure Lebron’s family doesn’t feel abandoned

well his steady girlfriend who he had a ‘commited relationship’ with (how committed was he really?) and 2 kids with doesn’t want him to go. She can’t make him not cheat on her and he is obviously going to (if he doesn’t already) now that he is in miami.

He was interviewed if he had support at home for his decision. he said ‘there are people in my house that do support me’. When asked if Savannah, his Girlfriend and High School Sweetheart supported him, he quickly reiterated what he said and changed the subject. During the decision, he kept talking about the blessing from his mom and how his mom will always support him. However, there is NO mention of his Kids or his Girlfriend

He is an adult now, not a kid. His partner and Kids should be more important for his decision than his mom. In an article by adrian wojanarowski, he talked about how they had to keep meetings short because of lebron’s attention span. There have also been questions about lebron’s maturity and even before this, he was called ‘baby’ a lot. I feel in many ways he may be a big baby and just a Momma’s boy. He wants to do ‘what momma says’. It doesn’t seem to matter to him the opinion of his girlfriend or what his kids think about leaving their hometown. No talk about that, but his mom supports him.

He is doing what he thinks is best for himself, not what he thinks is best for his family. The only way I see him staying with Savannah after this upcoming season is if he starts paying her millions of dollars to stay. A man does what is best for his family, his kids, and his significant other. A boy wants to gain the approval of his mother. Freud would have fun with this oedipus complex.

Many free agents took their wife’s opinions very seriously about where they wanted to go. In fact, the Amber Sabathia, and Leigh Williams were the pivitol points in CC Sabathia and Mark Texiera deciding to go to NYC. It doesn’t seem like he seriously considered her opinion on the matter.

I teach good life choices. That’s why I almost didn’t graduate High School.

I appreciate Male Beauty

by bross09 on Jul 30, 2010 5:09 PM CDT up reply actions  

I just thought I'd point out the faw in this analogy

Steve Carrell is giving NBC a year in an advance to plan for his departure from the show that he has starred in for the past 5-6 years, whereas the Free Agent just left with no sign of saying he wasn’t going to stay even though the team was trying to contact him for the month and a half leading up to his “moment.” If Steve Carrell had done that, even with his comedic talent he would find it hard to continue getting work that way. Just saying, your analogy is not working.

Unfortunately the legend of MJ has long surpassed the reality of MJ. -Joshua S.

by Marty Mart on Jul 28, 2010 11:55 PM CDT reply actions  

I understand your point, but the industries work different. No high profile athlete has never announced at the start of a season that he’ll be leaving the team to join another at the conclusion of a season.

by TheJoeOsborne on Jul 30, 2010 1:31 PM CDT up reply actions  

yes…but does that make Lebron’s decision better?

Carrell did like you are supposed to do in the working world. You are supposed to give ‘two weeks notice’. Carrell’s was longer, but the idea was so they would be able to make plans without him.

What lebron did is like the manager of Macy’s in NYC quitting on Black Friday, so the company has to try to hurry to get any sort of competent manager for the Holiday Season. The holiday season is very comparable to Free Agency, and Lebron’s importance on the team is similarly important to a manager. In that scenario, the Company can actually possibly bring up a lawsuit against you. Especially if it comes out that you have been talking with your friends and Bergdorf Goodman’s and Saks decide you will all work as managers at Saks and make a pact years before. That can get you sued.

I teach good life choices. That’s why I almost didn’t graduate High School.

I appreciate Male Beauty

by bross09 on Jul 30, 2010 5:13 PM CDT up reply actions  

This is it...

Maybe Lebron didn’t handle his departure with class, but he can do whatever he wants. The Cavs and their fans don’t own him. Athlete’s only have a limited window to perform at the highest level of sport, and he had a much better opportunity somewhere else.

Owners and teams give up on players all the time by trading them, cutting them, etc, so why is it so unfair for a player to give up on his team? I disagree that Lebron quit during the playoffs, but he did quit on his pursuit of a championship in Cleveland. So what though? Teams start over all the time, so why can’t a player?

Cleveland fans should keep in mind that Lebron will be a free agent again when he’s 30. Lebron originally showed loyalty to the franchise when he signed his extention at the end of the 05-06 season. Perhaps the fans and organization should show some gratitude, and maybe Lebron would consider coming back to deliver on his promise.

by TheJoeOsborne on Jul 30, 2010 1:27 PM CDT reply actions  

Wow. You still have no idea what you are talking about. One would think that after a bunch of people told you how ignorant you are about the subject, and given a week or two to do so, that you would actually look a thing or two up. One would be wrong though.

LeBoob would have been a restricted free agent, he would have had no choice but to stay with the Cavs, as they would certainly have matched any offer he was made. Instead they gave him what he wanted, a 3-year deal, rather than what the organization wanted, a 5-year deal. As usual it was the Cavs doing what they could to please LeDiva. However, he showed no loyalty, even back then.

At this point, despite the fact that he is obviously one of the best, if not the best, basketball player on the planet, I doubt many Cleveland fans would want LeBrat back. I for one, do not.

It’s real nice how you come back here, disregard every comment that shows just how wrong you are, then pretend as if you are qualified to offer the final word. Obviously, the real problem was that we ignorant Cleveland fans just weren’t grateful enough. You are a real class act.

Please do us all a favor and come to a Browns’ game wearing your new LeBaby Heat Jersey.

Every pessimist thinks himself a realist. In the case of Cleveland sports fans, they are probably right.

by evereye3 on Jul 31, 2010 5:23 AM CDT up reply actions  

Haha awesome reply. I would, as a social experiment, like that kid who did the Heat jersey at the Prog to show up in the Dawg Pound dressed the same. I would give him 10 minutes max.

by jsneides on Aug 2, 2010 8:36 PM CDT up reply actions  

Great Article

I enjoyed reading this. I too, think Lebron is getting too much heat for going to the Heat. I like the analogy, it was one I’ve never heard before. I agree that Lebron’s supporting cast was not championship material…when you match up the Cavs vs Lakers, vs the Magic, and vs the Celtics, you’ll see that Lebron is the best player then the next 3-6 best players are on the other team…that’s not a recipe for success. I believe the Cavs TRIED to improve their roster rectify this, and they made valiant efforts, but they were unable to. Lebron tried to get Bosh to come to CLE but he wouldn’t do it…and Lebron probably felt like nobody great would EVER come to CLE…also I’m not of the opinion that Lebron knew he was gonna leave CLE the whole time…as evidenced by the fact that he tried to get Bosh to come there too…

by fc3worships on Jul 31, 2010 5:43 PM CDT reply actions  

Lebron tried to get Bosh to come to CLE but he wouldn’t do it…and Lebron probably felt like nobody great would EVER come to CLE

nope. you are straight wrong. He talked about possibly getting bosh to come here, but Bosh would have come here if Lebron made a long Term committment to the team with Bosh on it. The cavs almost had Trevor ariza but he bailed. Lebron talked with him, but was completely noncommittal when talking about his future with cleveland. THAT was the selling point for Ariza who didn’t want to come here and then have Lebron leave.

Lebron never showed any sign of committment when talking to players when he did decide to recruit them in cleveland. He did show committment to the heat by signing for 6 years and afterward, decided to actively recruit Free Agents, including poaching guys form his former team (like Jawad williams, who would get minimal time in Miami, and much more in Cleveland and would be much more needed here). Lebron never actively recruited FAs like he has done. What does that look like? it looks like he never really was committed to this team.

also I’m not of the opinion that Lebron knew he was gonna leave CLE the whole time…as evidenced by the fact that he tried to get Bosh to come there too…

So that is evidence enough to disprove the mounds of evidence that he had decided years ago to leave cleveland? If Lebron made a committment to cleveland, we WOULD have bosh. NO QUESTION. the problem was that Lebron did not want to commit long term to the team.

I teach good life choices. That’s why I almost didn’t graduate High School.

I appreciate Male Beauty

Intensive Purposes? I could care less...

by bross09 on Aug 1, 2010 1:23 PM CDT up reply actions  

Mother *#$&%!

I thought this was going to be a strategy for defending Lebron when the Cavs play them not this crap.

by throwback on Aug 4, 2010 3:15 PM CDT reply actions   1 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

FearTheSword(FTS) is the ultimate independent resource for the Cleveland Cavaliers on the web. We look to provide hardcore Cavaliers fans positive, independent insight about the Cavs, 24/7/365!
Start posting about the Cavaliers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Delonte joins Shaq in Beantown, signs with Celtics
Iphone-app-logo_small
My NBA Power Rankings
Iphone-app-logo_small
The King’s Mental Note
Small
Samuels- a "3" or a "4"?
Small
What to do now and how to make the playoffs by 2012
Small
Things to chant when the "King of Quit" returns to Cleveland
Small
WE BLEED SPORTS BACKS LEBRON...MUST READ ARTICLE
Small
Dan Gilbert's "Decision"
Small
Shaq's Destiny Realized....
145417180_476760366_0_small
What would you do if you were the Cavaliers' GM for this upcoming season?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Socialize With FearTheSword

Facebook_badge_medium_medium_medium
Black_generated_button
Fts_email_medium



SBNation.com Recent Stories

NEW YORK CITY NY - AUGUST 12:  Kevin Durant #5 looks on during the World Basketball Festival USAB Showcase at Radio City Music Hall on August 12 2010 in New York City. (Photo by Chris Trotman/Getty Images for Nike) +4 updates

FIBA World Championships 2010: Team USA Routs Iran 88-51, Clinches Top Spot In Group B

FILE - This Feb. 21, 2010, file photo shows Denver Nuggets head coach George Karl before an NBA basketball game against the Boston Celtics,  in Denver. Karl will miss Wednesday night's,  March 10, 2010, game at Minnesota as he undergoes another round of cancer treatment.  (AP Photo/David Zalubowski, File) +4 updates

Nuggets Coach George Karl Says He'll Return To Coaching Next Season

Cleveland Cavaliers' Delonte West, right, shoot over Indiana Pacers' Jeff Foster in the first half of a NBA basketball game in Indianapolis, Monday, April 13, 2009.  (AP Photo/Michael Conroy) link

Celtics Sign Free Agent Delonte West

More from SBNation.com >


Owner/General Manager/Head Coach

Fts_small_small John Bena (aka CavsBlogger)

Asst. Coach

Small AncientMariner

Picme_small FTSmatt

Cavs_small FTSMatthew